Disclaimer: I write from a Christian perspective, interweaving spiritual insights with practical communication strategies. Whether or not you share this faith view, you’re still invited to explore the core idea: that clarity and kindness often get lost behind the word “but.” My hope is to encourage more honest conversations and self-talk, free of contradictory excuses.
Why “But” Feels So Dismissive
How many times have you heard a sentence start positively, only to unravel after the word “but”? Someone says, “I appreciate your feedback, but…” and you brace yourself for a dismissal of everything they just acknowledged. It’s a linguistic sleight of hand—signaling that the initial affirmation wasn’t entirely genuine. The phrase before “but” often feels erased or minimized, negating the emotional relief or validation you were beginning to receive.
This phenomenon crops up not only in conversations with others but also in our self-talk. For example, you might tell yourself, “I’m going to exercise and get healthier, but I’m just too busy right now.” In an instant, your resolve evaporates. Using “but” as a pivot can conveniently shelter us from accountability, giving us an out to maintain the status quo without fully rejecting the idea.
Biblically, we’re encouraged to let our “yes be yes” and our “no be no” (Matthew 5:37), implying that clarity and honesty matter more than sugarcoating. When we add a “but” after a supportive statement—like “I love you, but…”—we erode trust. The love you just proclaimed feels diluted by the objection that follows. Essentially, you’re indicating, “I’m only nice until I drop the hammer.”
In general, none of us want to be the person who leads others on with half-truths. Yet “but” often slips into conversations to soften a blow or stay “polite.” The trouble is, people sense the hidden disclaimer. Instead of building goodwill, it fosters confusion or suspicion. It’s not about grammar—“but” has its legitimate uses. The concern is how often we use it to mask or negate what we just said, rendering relationships shallow and our own promises shaky.
Recognizing how “but” can undermine sincerity helps us rethink how we communicate. If we truly want to express affection, agreement, or commitment, we might choose alternative phrasing that conveys nuance without undoing our initial words. By removing or at least minimizing “but,” we offer honesty and directness, fostering clearer, deeper connections.
Being Kind vs. Being “Nice”
A key reason people hide behind “but” is the fear of sounding mean or blunt. We want to appear kind, so we start with a comforting phrase—“I love your idea”—only to tack on a “but” that reveals our real opinion: “but I think it needs a lot more work.” Instead of honest dialogue, we create confusion. “Kindness” in this scenario becomes a veneer, blocking authentic transparency.
True kindness, however, doesn’t require veiled compliments. It means caring enough to offer truth constructively. If a friend’s business pitch genuinely needs major refinement, you can say, “I value your creativity, and I see areas we can improve to strengthen it.” The “and” signals additive support rather than a contradictory pivot. The difference might feel subtle, but it transforms your feedback from a contradiction into a collaborative encouragement.
In the biblical sense, kindness doesn’t shy away from truths that may be hard to hear; it simply delivers them in love. If Jesus had walked around offering half-hearted flattery, we wouldn’t see the strong, redeeming honesty He modeled. Real kindness respects the other person’s dignity enough to be forthright. Conversely, “niceness” can be hollow—an attempt to keep the peace while never addressing the real issue.
Likewise, in self-talk, opting for “and” or direct statements can reframe your commitments. Instead of “I plan to save money, but there’s no way I can cut expenses,” try: “I plan to save money, and I’ll start by rethinking my monthly subscriptions.” Removing the “but” invites problem-solving and positivity rather than self-sabotage. You give your mind a path forward instead of an excuse to quit.
Ultimately, this shift from “nice” half-truths to genuine kindness fosters better relationships and personal accountability. People sense your sincerity; they feel truly heard and not undermined by a sudden pivot. You also stop lying to yourself—trading illusions for honest steps toward growth.
Overcoming the “But” Habit in Daily Communication
Breaking free from “but” overuse requires intentionality. First, recognize the habit. Notice how often you’re about to say something affirmative, only to tack on a quick “but.” By catching that moment, you can pause and choose alternative words. Practice phrases like, “I appreciate your effort, and here’s how I think we can improve,” or “I value your expertise, and I have a different perspective.”
Secondly, if you truly disagree with someone’s statement, it might be better to say, “I see where you’re coming from, and I have concerns about…” rather than invalidating them with a quick “but.” The tiny tweak from “but” to “and” can keep the conversation collaborative rather than adversarial. This approach is especially powerful in feedback sessions at work or in delicate family discussions.
In personal goals, watch out for the “I want to do X, but…” statements that undermine your commitment. For instance, if you typically say, “I’d like to wake up earlier, but I’m not a morning person,” attempt: “I’d like to wake up earlier, and I’ll experiment with going to bed 30 minutes sooner.” Now you’ve replaced a barrier with a plan. You shift from excuse to execution, which can spark momentum.
There may still be times where “but” is appropriate for contrasting two ideas. The goal isn’t to erase the word from your vocabulary entirely—it’s to avoid using it in a way that backtracks on your positive or loving intent. Like any language pattern, changing how you speak takes practice. Mentors or friends can help hold you accountable, pointing out if you default to overusing “but” in ways that diminish clarity.
Ultimately, letting go of “but” fosters deeper trust in your relationships. People feel that what you say is cohesive and authentic, not full of disclaimers that nullify your initial warmth. Over time, this consistency in speech and behavior builds a reputation of reliability—a characteristic the Bible champions, encouraging us to let our “yes be yes” and our “no be no” (Matthew 5:37).
Removing Contradictions in Self-Talk and Spiritual Growth
While “but” can harm interpersonal communication, it also sabotages spiritual and personal growth. If you pray for wisdom or discipline yet constantly say, “I want to follow God, but I’m too flawed,” you’re effectively negating your faith statement. Yes, humility is vital, but humility doesn’t mean you cancel out God’s promises with “but” statements that highlight your limitations over His sufficiency.
Scripture reminds us that “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me” (Philippians 4:13). If you add “but I don’t think I can handle this challenge,” you create a double-minded stance that undermines confidence. Instead, try adopting an “and” approach: “I believe God empowers me, and I’ll seek practical resources to help navigate this challenge.” That shift unites faith and action rather than letting them conflict.
This also applies to sin struggles or personal development. Saying, “I know I should avoid gossip, but it’s so tempting” becomes an internal permission slip to keep gossiping. By removing the “but,” you can phrase it differently: “I know I should avoid gossip, and it’s challenging, so I’ll hold myself accountable with a friend or spiritual mentor.” You replace the excuse with a plan for growth.
In your broader spiritual life, discarding “but” when affirming truths or setting intentions can deepen your trust in God’s promises. You’re no longer ceding half the statement to doubt. You’re choosing a fully aligned confession of faith. Over time, your words shape your mindset, and your mindset shapes your choices—this is the biblical principle of “as a man thinketh in his heart, so is he” (Proverbs 23:7).
By bridging the gap between your beliefs and your actions, removing contradictory “buts” fosters greater integrity in your walk with God. People around you see that you don’t waffle back and forth, proclaiming one thing only to reverse it in the same breath. Instead, you stand firm, echoing sincerity in your speech and consistency in your life—hallmarks of a faith that resonates deeply.
Embracing Clarity and Consistency in Our Words
“Getting rid of but” might sound like a small language tweak, but its implications reach far into how we interact with others and ourselves. Each time we say, “I love you, but…” or “I respect you, but…” we inadvertently weaken the power of our initial statement. We convey that the disclaimers matter more than the initial positivity or empathy. And in a world starved for genuine connection, such disclaimers rarely build trust.
Choosing to replace or reduce “but” fosters clarity and consistency. We no longer undercut our first thought with a contradictory second. Instead, we can use “and” to expand the conversation, acknowledging complexities without negating the goodwill we started with. Or we can just be direct about our concerns, trusting that honesty—delivered with kindness—is often better than sugar-coated indecision.
From a faith standpoint, this shift aligns with Jesus’ call for us to let our “yes be yes” and our “no be no.” Removing the “but” fosters unity between words and actions, ensuring we’re not projecting a half-truth that we then revoke. And that sincerity translates into deeper relationships, where people see that our statements come from a place of integrity, not superficial politeness.
In personal growth, avoiding “but” helps us keep commitments to ourselves. The difference between “I plan to lose weight, but I hate exercise” and “I plan to lose weight, and I’ll start by doing 15-minute walks daily” is huge. The latter frames a solution instead of an excuse. It might be uncomfortable, requiring discipline, but it opens a path forward rather than slamming the door shut.
Ultimately, removing contradictions in our speech can transform how others perceive us and how we perceive ourselves. We step into a space where our affirmations carry weight and our criticisms or suggestions don’t erase the care we initially conveyed. In a society overflowing with half-commitments and diluted truths, a language of clarity and consistency stands out. Let’s strive for speech that builds up, fosters trust, and remains anchored in humility—and let’s replace “but” with honest, constructive communication that truly serves.
Comments